Handsaws: Part 1 - Canadian Woodworking Magazine

Tool Review

handsaws_lead

Handsaws: Part 1



Part 1: Western Saws
There is a level of satisfaction and enjoyment I get from hand planing a surface or hand sawing a tenon that I don’t get in using a jointer or table saw. Maybe it has something to do with the whining noise and shower of sawdust. Or maybe it’s that intimacy you develop with a well-made, finely tuned hand tool.
 
Whatever it is, I like hand tools. So I was quite excited at the prospect of trying out saws from some of the leading manufacturers. In this first of a two-part series, I’ll cover Western style saws and in Part 2, Japanese style saws.
 
Stanley Tools needs no introduction. They’ve been around since the 1840s, and produce about every kind of hand tool known to man. Bahco Tools is Snap-On Inc. is Sandvik (corporate amalgamation). Sandvik has long been synonymous with quality and innovation in hand tools. Thomas Flinn has been in the saw business since 1923, and the Pax line has been continuously produced for an amazing 225 years. Flinn is the only company that exclusively manufactures handsaws. Lie-Nielsen produces the finest hand planes available today, and are carrying on that tradition of quality with their handsaws.
 
Briefly, Western saws can be loosely divided into three categories. Backsaws – including gents, dovetail, tenon, mitre and inlay saws – have a rigid spine attached to the blade. Most fine woodworking saws on the market fall into this category. Frame saws – which have a blade under tension between two fixed ends – include frame, veneer, bow, bucksaws, coping, fret and jeweller saws. Finally, we have handsaws which have a wide blade fixed to a single handle. These include crosscut, rip, panel and general purpose saws. A good overview of handsaws is found in Graham Blackburn’s “Traditional Woodworking Hand Tools” (Random House).
 
I began by laying out the saws and conducting a quick visual inspection of the blades, teeth, rigid backs and handles. There were no glaring deficiencies. I then made a prescribed set of cuts on hardwood and softwood with each saw (flush, tenon, mitre and dovetail as appropriate for the saw). For convenience I have grouped the saws into five categories. Measurements are shown in inches, and prices in Canadian dollars (rounded to the nearest dollar and without shipping and taxes; US dollars converted at 1.45).
 

handsaws_1
Gents
The Stanley saw has the widest kerf and roughest cut. The handle is small, and not as comfortable as the others. It’s also about twice the price of the other saws. The Sandvik (bottom in photo above), with a thinner blade and finer set produced a noticeably better cut, and the handle was a bit more comfortable. Both the Stanley and Sandvik seem more suited for the carpenter or home handyman. The Thomas Flinn (Pax) saws (fixed handle - top in photo above) produced excellent cuts and, at under $20, are excellent values. The teeth on the offset handle Pax are only set on one side, which helps account for its narrower kerf. Both have very comfortable rosewood handles with brass spines and fittings. I found the offset handle a bit more awkward to use, although this may be due to my unfamiliarity with this style. Nonetheless, the Pax gent saws are excellent.


 Stanley 15-252Sandvik 312Pax OffsetPax Fixed
Overall Length151516 1/213 3/8
Blade Length9 3/49 3/4108
Blade Height1 3/41 1/21 1/41 3/4
Pitch13151520
Thickness.030.022.022.022
Kerf.042.030.025.027
Tooth Cutcrosscutcrosscutriprip
Temperednoyesnono
Price$39$22$20$17

handsaws_2
Tenon and Dovetail
These are gorgeous saws that feel wonderful in the hand. They cut smoothly and quickly. The Pax tenon saw (bottom in photo above) the largest and heaviest in the group has a solid feel to it, with excellent balance. A commanding presence. The Lie-Nielsen (Independence) Dovetail (top in photo above) is the smallest and lightest. Like holding a butterfly in your hand. The Pax saws come with a traditional closed style handle (an optional open handle is available), while the Independence saws come with the open handed pistol grip. I found that the pistol style handle offered better control: you can really feel whether the saw is being held in the correct position. The hardened steel blades and brass fittings on both the Pax and Independence saws are top of the line. In a fine cutting Western style saw, these are unsurpassed in quality. The Pax saws are less than half the price of the Independence saws. The question, then, comes down to style preference and price.


 Pax
Tenon
Independance
Carcass
Pax
Dovetail
Independance 
Dovetail
Overall Length17 1/41613 1/814
Blade Length121189
Blade Height3 1/82 1/42 3/81 5/8
Pitch13152015
Thickness.027.020.020.020
Kerf.033.025.025.023
Tooth Cutcrosscutcrosscutcrosscutrip
Temperednononono
Price$94$192$94$175

handsaws_3
Mitre
It seems to me that mitre saws are slowly fading into the sunset. Pity though.

Coupled with a good mitre box, they make quick work on accurate 45° and 90° angles. The Stanley 15-672 with its triple edged tooth design cuts very fast, but at the expense of smoothness. The Stanley 15-636 (see photo above) and the Sandvik 318 cut slower but produced smoother cuts. For cutting mitres on the job, either of these two will do, with the advantage that you can re-sharpen the Stanley 15-636 (teeth are not tempered). The handles were comfortable on all three saws.


 Stanley 15-672Stanley 15-636Sandvik 318
Overall Length17 1/419 1/416
Blade Length121412
Blade Height3 1/43 1/83 1/2
Pitch121313
Thickness.040.030.027
Kerf.058.041.027
Tooth Cutcrosscutripcrosscut
Temperedyesnoyes
Price$35$22$31

handsaws_4
Handsaws
Every shop needs a good crosscut saw for preparing rough stock. All these saws produced cuts of comparable quality. The Pax (top in photo - left) has a slightly smoother cut than the rest. It has excellent feel and heft, and with a handle that is 2” wide, is best suited for those with large hands. It also has that nice skewed back. The classic looking Sandvik 277 (bottom in photo above pg 21) is, like the Pax, taper ground, and probably better suited for someone with a longer arm. An advantage of either of these saws is that they can be re-sharpened. The Stanley, with its aggressive tooth pattern, cut the fastest. It lacked the balance of the Pax or Sandvik 277. The Sandvik 3090, with its ultra modern look, is the saw that seems tailor made for the work site. It has a very comfortable handle, silicon treated rust resistant blade, is lightweight and has excellent cutting properties.


 PaxSandvik
277
Stanley
20-065
Sandvik
3090
Overall Length25 5/829 5/829 5/822 3/4
Blade Length22262619 1/2
Blade Height5 1/45 1/25 1/24 3/4
Pitch10 81211
Thickness.037.039.035.045
Kerf.060.062.062.063
Tooth Cutcrosscutcrosscutcrosscutcrosscut
Temperednono yesyes
Price$65$76$48$43

handsaws_5
General Purpose
Stanley tools typically have induction-hardened teeth with an aggressive tooth design that incorporates three cutting surfaces. Sandvik saws incorporate a universal toothing pattern that has every third tooth short and set, while the other two teeth are straight and unset. Both companies make a number of saws that fit into the “General Purpose” category. These saws are often referred to as box saws or short cut saws, and can withstand rough handling better than others. They are ideal for toting around the work site or home. They do a decent job crosscutting or ripping, and you can use the handles to quickly layout 90° and 45° angles. The cuts made by these saws were fairly similar, with the Sandvik 300 (bottom in photo above) producing the narrowest kerf, and the Stanley (top in photo above) cutting the fastest. The handles of the Sandvik 2500 and Stanley are particularly comfortable. The teeth are impulse hardened. They make an excellent companion to the larger handsaws.


 Sandvik
2500XT
Stanley
20-045
Sandvik
300
Overall Length22 1/21816 1/2
Blade Length18 3/41513 3/4
Blade Height4 3/84 1/43 3/4
Pitch10915
Thickness.037.037.029
Kerf.061.060.038
Tooth Cutcrosscutcrosscutcrosscut
Temperedyesyesyes
Price$38$36$20

Summary
As with any hand tool, when purchasing a new saw you need to think carefully about its intended use. It is unlikely that any one saw will serve all you needs. In general, a good quality saw will last you many years. Saws that do not have tempered teeth, can last a lifetime, with proper sharpening and setting.
 
The photo below shows cuts from four saws (from left to right, Pax Gents, Pax Tenon, Independence Dovetail and the Stanley 15-636 Mitre saw). As expected, saws meant for general crosscut and rip work give the roughest cuts. With increasing point size the set becomes finer and the cuts get better. In general, all the saws I looked at cut reasonably fast. Perhaps, for carpenters, the speed of cutting may be an important consideration but, for most woodworkers, the quality of the cut is more of an issue. And if you do a lot of handwork, then the feel and balance of the tool is also an important consideration.
 
The Pax and Independence saws are clearly more suited for fine work, while the Sandvik and Stanley seem more positioned for general purpose sawing.
 
While Western style saws still dominate the market, Japanese saws are makingbig inroads. In the next issue we’ll look at some traditional and contemporary Japanese saws.

Sources:
Stanley - www.stanleyworks.com - 1-800-263-6292 Available from most hardware stores across Canada, including Canadian Tire, Home Hardware, and Home Depot
Sandvik - www.bahco.com - 1-800-296-4787 Available from House of Tools, Home Hardware, Revey, Pro Hardware, Home Depot, Reno Depot, TSC Stores, Kents, Rona, and The Building Box
Pax - www.flinn-garlick-saws.co.uk Available from the Promax Tool Corp - www.promaxtool.com - 1-877-967-8966
Independance - www.lie-nielsen.com Available from American Craftsman Publications - 1-877-967-5966



CARL DUGUAY is a writer and woodworker

from Sidney, British Columbia.